Endless Summer Vacation Alert.
Updates will resume as soon as the current great surfing conditions drift south.
|
Weekly Business Buzz List
Hot topics this week in the business community. Which is number one? You decide. Got a candidate? Drop me a line.
é Customer Service
It's amazing how many of the recession-era ideas that have been emerging from the big management consulting groups can be boiled down to this simple, old-fashioned concept. The catchy phrases may sound new - "customer value growth!" - but the strategy is basically the same one that always makes sense when times are tough: keep your current customers happy.
é Board helpers
No one would put up with their inefficiencies if they were at the bottom of the org chart instead of at the top. But, until recently, companies were inclined to cut their corporate boards a lot of slack. Now of course everybody's hoping that corporate boards will step in and help to clean things up. But there's one problem: the average corporate board is still a laughably inefficient organization. A number of entrepreneurs see this as an opportunity.
é
Market Dynamics
Holland's 17th-century tulip mania is frequently cited as a cautionary tale about the dynamics of wild speculations. But that country's continued dominance of the worldwide flower market contains some instructive lessons about how markets create and sustain their advantages. It turns out there's a lot more to creating a market than just low prices.
ê Web services
Microsoft (.NET) and Sun (java) are trying their hardest to introduce this concept to the business world, but so far it hasn't stuck. A prediction: Web services won't catch on until a few broad, easy-to-grasp examples are out there working and making money for someone.
| |
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence, August 4
Consultant Michael Katz admits "it was a slow day" in the winter of 2001 when he decided to see just how responsive commercial Web sites were to customer inquiries. He chose a mix of 36 national and New England brand-name companies, visited each, found the "contact" button, and e-mailed a simple, typical consumer question.
The purpose of his test was to measure the response time at each site. Katz was surprised by the results: 19% never replied, and although the top five responded in under an hour, the rest of the responses trickled back over the next seven days.
Read more
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence, July 28
No one would put up with their inefficiencies if they were at the bottom of the org chart instead of at the top. But, until recently, companies were inclined to cut their corporate boards a lot of slack.
If company directors were perpetually playing catch up, flipping through crucial documents on the flight to the quarterly meeting, that was the price paid for having very important, very busy executives on your board.
Read more
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence, July 21
How many times have you heard the story about tulip mania in 17th-century Holland - how the craze spread so wildly that people were ultimately investing their life savings in a single bulb, and how the market crashed horribly, and how it is an instructive parallel to the dot-com boom and bust?
Ajit Kambil can also tell a good story about tulips and Holland, but his tales have a much different spin. Kambil, an associate partner and senior research fellow at Accenture's Institute for Strategic Change in Cambridge, is a student of markets, and his flower stories have a "where are they now" quality. Because despite that catastrophic collapse of the tulip market, Holland remains the world center for flowers, tulips included. And this in a country that has comparatively high labor costs, expensive farmland, and less-than-ideal weather.
Read more
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence, July 14
Let me tell you a story. A team of five researchers, looking for innovative and effective leadership practices, interviews a range of CEOs and human-resources executives. The researchers are seeking techniques that companies use to groom leaders. They find that one initiative outperforms many of the others: storytelling.
Douglas Ready, the president of Lexington's International Consortium for Executive Development Research, the group that conducted the study, is a trifle embarrassed by the word "storytelling." He prefers "leader-led development" or "executive dialogue," but he really can't argue with the headline the editors put over his report in the issue of the MIT Sloan Management Review that will be published tomorrow: "How Storytelling Builds Next-Generation Leaders."
Read more
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence, July 7
The assignment was cruel and unusual, even by business school standards: figure out what's really going on in that much-hyped, supposedly emerging technology called "Web services."
The students in the Boston University School of Management's MS.MBA program had just one week this summer to make sense of a category that even trend-conscious technology geeks have trouble explaining.
Read more
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence, June 30
They are keeping up with trends at the Tweeter Center, and not just musical ones. This year, there are 23 new rows of seats at the Mansfield outdoor concert facility, squeezed in between the high-priced seats under the pavilion and the open seating on the lawn. Although the center's capacity is unchanged, there's now a new price point, "reserved lawn."
The trendwatchers at the Tweeter Center obviously heard the buzz: In tough economic climate, pricing strategy is hot.
Read more
A WALK IN THE WEB: The fake world
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence, June 23
The analyst, from a major East Coast technology consulting firm, was nursing an after-lunch cup of coffee and describing one of the rock-solid revenue generators for his company.
"When our consultants start talking to a firm about outsourcing information technology, sometimes that company's IT department tries to protect it's turf," he said, shaking his head. "That's fruitless."
Read more
A WALK IN THE WEB: Best foot forward: Soccer
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence, June 16
Why were the US intelligence agencies unable to uncover the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11? Philip Evans believes that their organizational structures were partly to blame.
According to Evans, senior vice president of the Boston Consulting Group and the coleader of the firm's work on "the new economics of information," the hierarchical nature of the CIA and FBI was ill suited to pick up the "weak and noisy signals" received before the attacks.
Read more
This week's Best of the Web is about BBQ.ABOUT.COM. It's a website devoted to the people obsessed with grilling and BBQ recipes.
A WALK IN THE WEB: All about babies
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence, June 9
Boston is awash in entrepreneurial advice.
Last week, for example, you could choose between a start-up "bootcamp" at Hale & Dorr, the Boston law firm, and a "Start-Up Clinic" at the MIT Enterprise Forum of Cambridge. This week, some local entrepreneurial eminences will be back at the forum speaking on the topic, "Entrepreneurial Lessons Learned."
Read more
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
Behaviorial science is "like a vineyard" to Richard Chase, a professor at the University of Southern California's Marshall School of Business in Los Angeles. "I like to go out there to pick ideas," he says.
Chase runs into many other business and management thinkers in those fertile fields where psychological researchers study how and why people act the way they do - people like Richard Thaler of the University of Chicago, who uses "behavioral economics" to explore many of the seemingly irrational factors that drive financial decision making.
Read more
A WALK IN THE WEB: Hacked to bits
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
It seems as if brands are pairing up everywhere these days: in traditional relationships (the Eddie Bauer Ford Explorer) and more exotic threesomes (the Shell Chase MasterCard).
When I mentioned this to Kevin Lane Keller, professor of marketing at the Amos Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth College, he suggested I conduct some primary field research.
Read more
A WALK IN THE WEB: Back together again
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
I didn't expect to be talking baseball and fashion with Richard Hunter, an expert in how information technology is influencing society. He is well known for painting particularly scary scenarios around issues like cyberterrorism and identity theft and also focuses on the effects new technologies are having on business.
But when I sat down with him last week while he was in Boston for the day and asked him about the business side of his research, he began talking sports.
Read more
This week's Best of the Web is about Tripadvisor.com. It's a website where real people can rate hotels across the country and all over the world.
Web Watch: Luke, I am your browser
Posted: May 16, 2002
Wired News
interviews Associate Prof. Candida Brush about her new study aimed at
dispelling the "biz-woman mystique." Mass
High Tech checks it out, too.
A Duke student got an idea from a guest lecturer and turned it into
something that won $50K in an entrepreneurship competition called the 2002 Duke Start-up Challenge a
few months later. The all undergraduate Sun Dance Genetics
team also hit it big.
And if you want to successfully navigate the next waves of technology, says
HBS professor Debora
L. Spar, it's critical to gain a perspective on the rise of
innovation, markets, and rules.
Business Intelligence Morning After Feedback...
Someone from the Boston Chapter of the American Marketing Association e-mailed me to say the group was having a thing Wednesday night at the Ritz Carlton featuring Ken Kimmel, Vice President of Marketing for Dunkin’ Donuts and Kenny Lawrence, Director of Creative Services and Marketing for Viacom Boston. Check their Web site for more info.
Another correspondent sent a link to an article on trust-based marketing from ClickZ, the e-mail marketing hub.
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
It was an extremely attentive, if skeptical, audience of marketing professionals who gathered at the Boston Park Plaza hotel Tuesday afternoon to learn how to deal with a rising force in the marketplace: customer power.
The session, sponsored by the American Marketing Association, was designed to address that vague, unsettled feeling among many companies that their customers have turned the tables on them.
Read more
Business Intelligence Spillover
The site to check if you want to see the trust-based approach in action is Auto Choice Advisor, the GM site that will give you some unbiased information on cars, even non-GM cars. Patricia Seybold is also a good source on Customers. She's got a relatively new book on the topic.
Harvard Business School professor Stefan Thomke and MIT Sloan School of Management's Eric von Hippel suggest that you stop listening closely to your customers—and instead give them tools for creating their own products.
Finally Jupiter Media Metrix is suggesting that companies use the Web to weed out bad customers.
BTW BusinessWeek calls this whole thing the Customer Economy.
This week's Best of the Web is Online Games. Looks like it's a dogfight between Microsoft's The Zone, and Pogo.com.
Check out the newest addition to this site - a resources page.
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
Yossi Sheffi's large office at MIT is nearly wallpapered with algorithms. The equations cascade down the large easel pads on one side of the room, across an expanse of whiteboard on the other.
This isn't surprising. Sheffi, who is the director of MIT's Center for Transportation and Logistics, is well known in his field for bringing mathematical rigor to the supply chain, the crucial bucket brigade that runs through the center of a huge swath of the global economy (from "your supplier's suppliers to your customers' customers" is the way Sheffi describes it)
Read more
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
Boxes and boxes of ideas are stacked up all around the offices of the Big Idea Group, three floors above the main street of this Southern New Hampshire city.
The ideas, from inventors around the country, have arrived in all sorts of containers, large and small. Rough prototypes peek from the open boxes, surrounded by snow drifts of styrofoam peanuts.
Read more
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
The two leaders of "The Agile Workplace" research project did not have to look far to find vivid examples for their study.
Michael Joroff, a senior lecturer at MIT's School of Architecture and Planning, spends just one-third of his working time in a small office on the MIT campus that he shares with a colleague. The rest of the time he's either working in his home office in a converted barn in Concord or logging in from remote locations around the world.
Read more
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
It was while scanning the "Tips" section of "Laying Off Employees" on the Web that I realized I had found a Cliffs Notes version of Harvard Business School.
There was something about the way this online lesson efficiently outlined the steps for preparing for this "stressful conversation" that seemed to pull together, in shorthand fashion, the confident assurance one would expect a Harvard MBA to bring to the situation.
"In a calm, dignified tone," it advises, "reiterate the reasons for the layoff that you explained earlier to your group (or explain them for the first time if the layoff is occurring immediately). If the employee asks, `Why me?' emphasize that all layoff decisions were based on company strategy and work roles, not individual performance."
Sounds both authoritative and effective, doesn't it?
That's the idea behind Harvard ManageMentor, the "performance support tool for managers in a hurry" published by Harvard Business Online, a division of Harvard Business School Publishing.
ManageMentor is a sort of "Harvard Business School to go," designed to offer just-in-time information for managers facing challenging situations. And it's about more than laying people off. Thirty-three management topics get the Cliffs Notes treatment in the latest version of the system, which was released late last week.
"Making a Presentation," "Running a Meeting," "Assessing Performance," "Giving and Receiving Feedback" -- topics that give managers sweaty palms are the purview of this series. But what's particularly interesting is not the subject matter, but the presentation. Instead of selling individual segments to consumers, Harvard Business Online markets the entire system to corporations, which install it on the company intranets for easy access by managers and employees using their office computers.
"These are timeless issues that every manager has to deal with," said Jon Winder, senior vice president of enterprise solutions at Harvard Business School Publishing. "Our idea was to boil the content down to something that would reward an investment of just five or 10 minutes."
And clicking around "Laying Off Employees" is like getting an instant refresher course: just the high points, nothing longer than a few paragraphs, all conveyed in a lean combination of tips, step-by-step guides, "core concepts," tools, self-evaluation questionnaires, and links to relevant articles.
Bouncing around the topic, it was easy to imagine a frantic manager on the verge of a layoff announcement taking a few minutes to run through it as a way of girding for the ugly job ahead.
The ManageMentor product, which consists of 33 modules, is not cheap, with a price that varies according to the size of the purchaser: from $3,000 a year (for companies with less than 50 employees) to $60,000 annually for companies with more than 10,000 employees. Yet since it was launched in 1998, more than 500 corporate sites have purchased the system, a testament to the increasing importance of corporate intranet-based professional development.
Donna Conlin, manager of executive development at Framingham-based Bose Corp., has been working with ManageMentor since 2000.
"We use it in two ways," she said. "First, as follow-up to our training that people can do on their own. We also use it to allow people to access information they need, when they need it, wherever they are."
Among the most popular modules at Bose: "Managing Your Career," "Giving and Receiving Feedback," "Setting Goals," and "Negotiating."
Liberty Mutual Insurance, in Boston, is another local ManageMentor customer. Among the most accessed modules, according to Rich Benner, Liberty Mutual's manager of Curriculum Development and Instructional Technology, are "Managing Difficult Interactions," "Retaining Valued Employees" and "Leading and Motivating."
Benner believes that these skeletal business topics are more than just radical summaries. They are an entirely new medium for professional instruction.
"They really have their own niche," he said. "They aren't like a workshop, where you have to sit in a classroom for eight hours; they aren't like CDs, which you have to order and wait for. The information is there when you need it: it's self-service.
"If you've got a problem now," he continued, "you can go to the intranet, get what you want, and make something happen."
Bose's Conlin agreed that the ManageMentor program has found a promising educational niche, although she put it more succinctly.
"It really fills the bill for users who are like, `I need a refresher, quick!"' she said.
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
The Center for Business Innovation in Cambridge's Kendall Square is combination corporate playground and think tank for Cap Gemini Ernst & Young, the Paris-based global information technology consulting firm.
The interior design, a cross between "Pee-wee's Playhouse" and "The Jetsons" (angular walls of mustard yellow, sage green, and powder blue intersecting with sheets of glass and whiteboard) screams that something futuristic is going on.
"We generally think three to five years into the future," a staffer told me as we stood on a swoosh of royal blue carpet in Cap Gemini's lobby.
But here's the problem: New technical ideas that are just over the horizon have gotten harder to sell.
John Parkinson, Cap Gemini's new chief technologist, who was in Cambridge for the afternoon, knows this too well. He doesn't really have an office - he lives outside Chicago - but floats among 20 of the firm's 200-plus offices.
A hung-over tech economy is the most obvious reason why new technical ideas are a hard sell, but Parkinson, who was camped out in a glass-enclosed conference room, easily ticked off four more factors: "buyer fatigue" from customers who had bought expensive software products and have yet to see related revenue results; a "commodification" of services that are now offered by major information technology consultants everywhere; a growing corps of ex-consultants at client companies who are cutting budgets for traditional consulting services; and an industry retreat from custom software in favor of off-the-shelf packages from major software companies.
Parkinson didn't appear to be too depressed about all this. In a physician-heal-thyself scenario, he says he has a new strategy for dealing with this innovation ennui, in which Cap Gemini shares the financial risk of new projects with clients.
"We should be willing to underwrite the value assertion that comes with the work," Parkinson said. Translation: Put your money where your mouth is.
Parkinson cited as an example the concept of "customer relationship management" systems designed to help companies learn more about their customers. These systems often involve a multimillion-dollar investment in software and technical engineering - just the sort of project many companies are reluctant to undertake these days.
"Let's say we advise a client to invest $10 million in a CRM strategy," Parkinson said. "And we claim that it will be worth $500 million a year in incremental revenue, and $100 million in reduced costs. And it will also result in a 20 percent increase in the company's stock price. I'm advocating that we offer to charge $2 million to do the work. If it all works, you pay us $18 million; if it delivers on just two of the items, give us $10 million. If none of it works, we'll give you the $2 million back."
Parkinson hopes this combination of risk sharing and performance guarantee will get clients to be more adventurous about taking on technology projects in tough times.
"It sounds logical, in these economic times," said Carl Frappaolo, executive vice president and cofounder of Delphi Group, the Boston tech consultancy. "It addresses that `prove it to me' response clients often have to consultants."
Ironically, Frappaolo recalled first seeing the shared risk idea during the dot-com boom, when consultants wanted clients to share the possible upside of projects.
"The idea then was, `you're going to make so much money from this project that we want a piece of it.' Now we're working the other side of the equation," he said.
Parkinson can point to one Cap Gemini project where the idea has already worked: a procurement system the company designed for the British Ministry of Defense to facilitate transactions with the Ministry's 32,000 suppliers. Cap Gemini structured the deal so the company was paid for each transaction. "The more the system is used, the more we get paid," Parkinson said. "So the pressure's on us to build the best possible system."
The risk partnership is not solely a defensive move. Parkinson hopes that in an era when IT services have become more or less a commodity, Cap Gemini's willingness to guarantee results will allow it to charge clients a premium.
There will still be plenty of "fixed-price" bids in the future, Parkinson said, but for those projects that involve skeptical partners, or new markets, Parkinson wants the company to make deals that are "significantly `gainshare' weighted."
In other words, "We'll put our money where our mouth is," Parkinson said.
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
Michael Shuman, who is pretty sure he's the lowest-paid member of Stanford Law School's class of '82, was sitting in the lavish dining room in the Executive Education Center at Babson College in Wellesley last Friday morning, talking about local economic models and chicken manure.
Shuman's resume, in his words, "screams progressive activist," including directorships of a variety of left-leaning policy groups. But a few years ago, the 46-year-old Shuman says, he got tired of "throwing rocks at businesses." Now he spends most of his time on the other side of the fence, talking to Chamber of Commerce groups, business-related conferences, and strategizing his entry into the chicken business.
Shuman is still a man with a cause, however; that cause is "local." And just like the good old days, he's in a David and Goliath struggle. Most business schools, like Babson, are still firmly in the grip of a global business model that celebrates economies of scale and free trade: Nike, Wal-Mart, Pepsi, etc.
Shuman is trying to sell a different vision.
"My main sermon is that locally owned development is a viable alternative to a global economy," he said. "I'm not really swimming against globalization per se, just the idea that bigger and global is always better, cheaper."
Last week, Shuman was in Wellesley to deliver his message to the Babson College community. He was a keynote speaker at the college's annual International Symposium on Spirituality and Business. Yet as he previewed his remarks over breakfast, it was clear he was not expecting "local" to be an easy sell, even to a potentially friendly crowd.
"Most communities believe that the ideal is to get a Toyota factory in your backyard and export your goods as widely as possible," he said. "That's taking advantage of the global economy."
Shuman argues against this approach by emphasizing the "economic multiplier" effect, which refers to the benefits that accrue to a community when a dollar is respent many times in the same place: You buy a dollar of your local plumber's time. He buys a sandwhich from the local cafe owner, who buys some chairs at the local furniture store. The greater the circulation of dollars, the higher the community's income, wealth and employment.
When dollars fly out of the community to outside businesses, the local economy suffers and sputters, Shuman says.
Still it's not an easy sell. So Shuman, who lives in Washington and maintains a busy lecture schedule, is always looking for models.
One of his favorites is the Green Bay Packers, a nonprofit company with thousands of shares mostly held by the local fans. He also celebrates community-supported agriculture, alternative energy companies, manufacturers who use recycled materials, and local savings banks.
But apparently talking about these local models is not enough. Shuman, ever the activist, wants to create one. So this spring he and a few colleagues are planning to launch a model chicken business on the eastern shore of Maryland.
Why? Eastern Maryland is one of the largest chicken-growing areas in the country, but Shuman says the industry is plagued by low pay, poor union relations, bad working conditions, and environmental insensitivity, dumping billions of pounds of chicken manure into the Chesapeake Bay every year.
If the state attempts to raise local standards, "the chicken companies threaten to move to Arkansas," Shuman said.
So Shuman is planning a locally owned, environmentally responsible chicken company.
"In the end, nothing is more persuasive than working models of these alternative business structures, and creating new exemplary models," he said.
Unfortunately when your passion is local, you don't make your models with Powerpoint slides and Excel spreadsheets. You make them with bailing wire and truckloads of manure, a fact that is probably just starting to dawn on Shuman.
Asked about his upcoming lecture schedule toward the end of breakfast, he paused briefly.
"Over the next six months," he said with just a trace of disbelief, "I think most of my life is going to be chicken."
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
The course should be called "Innovation," but because it's MIT the official title is more technical: "Generation of New Product and Service Concepts."
It's a core topic at MIT, whatever you call it, and it's a safe bet that many of the 35 students enrolled this semester are surprised by professor Eric von Hippel's message: if you want to develop major new products, do not study average users.
Instead, von Hippel urges students to focus on "lead users," people who push the limits of a product and can help companies discover ways to make improvements that will ultimately appeal to everyday users.
"Lead users have a high incentive to make improvements," von Hippel said in an interview last week. "They are ahead of the target market."
Asked for an example, von Hippel cited a case on sailboards developed by his doctoral student Sonali Shah. Originally designed for calm waters, sailboards were quickly adopted by Hawaiian windsurfers who began taking the boards into heavy surf and using them to perform somersaults. This required them to develop footstraps and other innovations. The manufacturers who discovered this practice were able to launch entirely new sailboards for the windsurfing market.
Von Hippel also cited the company that wanted to develop a nutritional product for weekend athletes. They asked nutrition scientists who worked with Navy Seals and Olympic athletes about the performance-enhancing food innovations they were using. Automobile brake manufacturers looking for advances, he notes, studied racecars and aerospace vehicles, which both have "extreme" braking needs. Von Hippel was on a roll.
"You want to see what kinds of things leading-edge users, whether individuals or companies, are developing on their own," said von Hippel. "The inventions are out there. The problem becomes search."
And how do you find these lead users?
The method von Hippel has developed involves networking with people who are "as expert as you can find" and doing two things: talking to them about their needs and their solutions; and asking them who knows more than they do.
"There's always someone who's more expert, and people in the field will help you get to them," von Hippel said. "Also, as you move along, you will be changing the questions to incorporate what you have learned."
The result is that your questions get better as you climb the food chain to the most advanced "lead users."
Von Hippel, who writes and consults about innovation (his Web site, www.leaduser.com, describes some of his outside projects) believes the "lead user" idea liberates companies from the pressure to constantly create innovation.
"Tapping into lead users gives firms a systematic way of generating breakthroughs," he said. "They no longer have to invent the solution on their own. They can incorporate out-of-the-box innovations which have been developed by lead users, and already proven under extreme field conditions."
Eventually, companies will incorporate these cutting-edge users more tightly into their development processes, von Hippel said. Already, recent advances in integrated chip design, for example, allow an individual user to design the chip he wants and submit that design to a chip company to be manufactured.
"As we get toward markets of one," von Hippel said, "manufacturers can no longer afford to figure out what each user wants. Their best approach in that case is to empower the user."
Von Hippel has been developing "toolkits" to enable just that: to give users more control over the development of their own custom solutions and innovations.
"It's kind of an evolving story," von Hipple said. "In the past, the approach was `find a need and fill it.' Finding lead users is an advance on that. But the future is even more radical: `empower the user."'
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
Corporate strategy guru Adrian Slywotzky heeded his own much-published advice before he started his most recent book: Study the customer.
The result: Slywotzky's latest project, which was released on Friday, isn't really a book, or even an e-book ("E-books are a flop," he said.) It's "a parable" titled "The Art of Profitability" that's available free on the Internet in a "channel" that includes multiple feedback options for readers.
Slywotzky is no techno-utopian flake. A vice president at Mercer Management Consulting in Lexington, he's in charge of developing the firm's business concepts. Two of his previous books, "Value Migration" and "Profit Zone," were mainstream business book successes, each selling upward of 100,000 copies in hardcover.
So what did Slywotzky learn about his customers that has caused him to ditch the traditional route in favor of an Internet venture? First, Slywotzky focused on the two primary customers for the kind of business books he writes: business students, whom Mercer Management recruits, and executives at companies that are Mercer clients or potential clients.
What he discovered, Slywotzky reported when I visited him in his Lexington office, was that traditional business books, the ones so prominently displayed in airport bookstores, are not doing an effective job of reaching these two target audiences.
"The typical business reader goes through 10 or 15 of these books a year," he said. "He just skims the book and moves on to the next one, without ever really getting engaged."
Most business books don't work for the author either.
"Somewhere between 1,000 and 1,300 business books are published every year," Slywotzky said. "The typical business book sells between 10,000 and 15,000 copies. There's not a lot of money in it. The time it takes to publish a book also prevents you from getting ideas out there quickly."
So Slywotzky hatched an idea to create a Zen-like parable on the subject of "how profit happens" and put it on the Web for free. The result is a Socratic dialogue between an aspiring businessman and a character named Zhou (a composite of two professors whom Slywotzky studied under: one at Harvard Law, the other at Harvard Business School. Yes, he attended both). Each of the book's 23 chapters is devoted to a separate "profit model." If you print it out, the project runs about 150 pages.
Mercer's manager of Internet marketing, Ellen Zanino, has built a "channel" for the project on the Mercer Web site that includes download options and feedback forms to encourage readers to engage in dialogue with Slywotzky about his ideas. Although the book is free, readers are required to register, increasing the connectivity between the author and readers. Slywotzky is working on incorporating some of the suggestions he's received during the project's beta period on the Web.
"The point was not to sell books, but to get the ideas out there in accessible fashion," Slywotzky said. "The aim is a good working relationship with these customers."
Most of the consulting firms that compete with Mercer - Bain, Boston Consulting Group, McKinsey - are also using the Internet to distribute their business ideas. Adobe's Portable Document Format is quickly becoming the default format for business articles, briefs, and white papers.
Boston advertising firm Partners+Simons has pushed the idea the furthest. Their library of nine online white papers is stylishly designed and prominently featured in Amazon's "e-Books & Documents" section. Last fall, one of their titles, "The Liberation of the Logo," which sells for $4.95, reached number three on the Amazon eBook best-seller list.
Mercer's Zanino is not surprised that online intellectual projects are multiplying. Business students are supremely comfortable online, she reports, and even senior executives are surprisingly fluent.
"Our studies of the market tell us that executives are much more comfortable with online content now," she said. "It's so fast and convenient that they've learned to use it."
A mass audience for a product such as "The Art of Profitability" is still a long way off, but for the two customer groups that Slywotzky is targeting, the Internet may already be the most efficient way to reach them. And Slywotzky thinks it's only going to get more efficient, as the business community mixes it up with this new medium.
"I expect that the amount of feedback we'll get on `The Art of Profitability' will taper off," he said. "But the amount of feedback we get on this application is going to increase."
Sunday Globe - Business Intelligence
Electronic updates are still streaming into NewRiver's computer system long after the sun sets on the Andover online financial services provider. On a typical day, between 1,000 and 2,000 filing modifications flow into NewRiver's databases, the very latest information on more than 26,000 mutual funds the company tracks.
The data arrive as late as 11 p.m. and have to be current by the start of the next trading day. But no one's losing sleep at NewRiver, at least not on this project. That's because the company's night shift, more than 150 strong, is located in New Delhi, where the sun is just starting to peek over the horizon as the last NewRiver employee heads home.
In the global version of 24/7, data-centric companies are using the earth's rotation to create around-the-clock operations. "If we didn't split the project between time zones, there's no way we could get it all done," says Craig Le Clair, NewRiver's executive vice president of brokerage services.
NewRiver's approach seems destined to catch on with a new generation of global firms. Amar Gupta, codirector of the Productivity from Information Technology program at MIT's Sloan School of Management, says he has seen it "from both sides, from the US and India." Acceptance of the idea, he says, has already turned "180 degrees."
"Years ago people in India and the United States thought the time difference was a negative," he says. "They thought it would hinder their ability to work with US firms. Now that's switched around - for many projects the time difference is a plus."
According to Gupta, Motorola Inc. is one of the companies that has pushed the concept furthest. Motorola has a chain of centers around the world that allows it to work on projects bucket-brigade style, "literally 24 hours a day."
At Motorola, a project can move with the sun from the United States to Europe to India to Australia and back to the United States. Three eight-hour shifts are possible in a 24-hour period.
"The challenge is developing the collaborative techniques so that you don't spend four hours explaining to the next person what you did in the previous eight," Gupta says.
Gupta believes the trend toward globe-trotting projects that never shut down will accelerate, because the approach saves time and labor costs.
"The cost of programming and data-entry labor in India, for a large multinational firm, is about a fourth of what it is in the US," Gupta says. `For companies that deal with very small Indian firms, the cost can be one-fifteenth."
Gupta foresees software programming projects that will use sophisticated workflow techniques to keep the work moving around the clock and around the globe, dramatically reducing development time and labor costs.
In the meantime, the first generation of global collaborations is primarily data-oriented, because such projects can easily be broken up. At NewRiver for example, the financial data stream into two parallel databases: one in Andover, one in New Delhi (about 10 and a half hours ahead). Every morning at 6:30 EST, the two databases automatically "handshake," synching up in preparation for the opening of the financial markets.
NewRiver chief technology officer Anil Gupta (no relation to MIT's Gupta) believes that his company's two-continent project is only the beginning.
"Once you are on the Internet, it doesn't matter whether you are in Andover or New Delhi," he said. "It's insane for companies not to make that work for them."
Posted: Tuesday, February 26, 2002
Post-Olympics withdrawal:
The Olympics are over and now it's back to regular television programming. What is a sports fanatic to do?
Through the power of the Web, you can challenge your Olympic intellect with a bit of trivia. This site flashes a different piece of trivia every 10 seconds, while this site provides a slew of miscellaneous trivia.
For those of you who haven't been following the Olympic games and are wondering what they're all about, this site is an exhibit about the original Olympic games in ancient Greece and explores the history, customs and events.
Just for fun:
Here's a tribute to the hair cut everyone loves to hate. That quintessential 80's do, the mullet. Rate one today! (Hit refresh to see the next photo)
See what happens when people try to eat 6 saltines in 60 seconds.
If you're pulling out the grill tonight due to the unseasonably warm temperature, you might want to get your friends together play a little cheese racing.
Posted: Friday, February 22, 2002
So what do people read on their ebooks anyway? Read this bestseller list from gemstar.
Looking to join an ebook club? Get everything from the skinny on new releases to excerpt previews and more.
Time profiles ebook websites for those interested in electronic publishing and converting to digital ebook files.
The Olympics are drawing to a close and it's almost time to reflect on this year's games.
- As we all know, technology can enhance any TV scenario. But it seems that none can match the power of TiVo, especially when it comes to the Olympics.
- One Olympic worker set up his own Olympic weblog. He catalogs the athletes he has met and the spectacles he has witnessed.
Just for (FRIDAY!) fun:
Do you need a vacation? Well, can't help you there, but check out these webcams for some great scenery.
Who said ecommerce can't be entertaining? See what interesting things are being auctioned off right now.
Thinking of making your own weblog, but you don't have the eye for design? This site is a collection of plain, CSS-intensive weblog layouts that are free for the taking!
Posted: Thursday, February 21, 2002
The Women in Engineering Organization launches a new site to "Introduce a Girl to Engineering Day."
Open eBook Forum is the Leading International Trade and Standards Organization for the eBook Industry. Find out what research they are doing and how to go into ebook business.
So what else can you do with an ebook reader anyway? Since the reader is a PDA, the uses are endless. Everything from creating shopping lists to using it as a flashlight!
Just for fun:
Crazy cats! No, seriously, they're crazy. A schizophrenic artist takes to drawing the cute and cuddly creatures with a interesting result.
Do you like to see amazing things? Do you regularly watch Fear Factor? Then check out The Guinness Book of World Records people use to show photos of record-breaking achievements and rate how amazing the record actually is.
Posted: Wednesday, February 20, 2002
The annual Sebold Conference and Exposition, a conference designed for "bringing the media technology community together," will continue through the weekend. The event comes complete with a letter from mayor of New York Rudolph Giulianni. The event will touch on subjects ranging from web development to ebooks and more.
Surfable Books is a new phenomenon in research according to Michael Hoey, CEO of the company.
Not sure how to format your latest literary creation? Check out this HTML versus PDF bake off. Also some suggestions on when to use each.
When Bill Gates promotes the computer tablet, he makes it look so...boring. But here are some creative ideas for what to do with these things.
Just for fun:
No one wants to admit it, but there are a lot of men who look like Kenny Rogers out there.
Have you ever thought, "What pre-1985 video game character am I?" Find out if you're a Pacman Ghost or a Frogger with this quiz.
Speaking of trivia, how about a little Simpsons trivia?
Posted: Tuesday, February 19, 2002
Sunday Globe - The company that scares Microsoft the most is not a company at all. It's a movement, "open-source software," and its best-known product, the Linux operating system.
But it isn't Microsoft's worries that interest Bob Wolf, a senior manager at the Boston Consulting Group, and Karim Lakhani, also a BCG consultant and doctoral student at MIT's Sloan School of Management. What interests them is whether the open-source phenomenon offers lessons for improving the way businesses organize themselves and work toward common goals.
According to Wolf and Lakhani, who have just completed what they describe as a "hacker survey" of 526 open-source software programmers, it does. And it promises to influence companies as they ponder how best to get the job done.
The open-source movement stands as the antithesis to the closed, proprietary product development system that Microsoft has used to dominate the personal computer desktop worldwide. If open-source had a motto, it might be: "Let all who are able contribute." Under open-source, thousands of volunteer programmers communicate over the Internet to create, and continually improve, computer software products. Linux is their biggest success and has become so popular that some think it could evolve into a significant challenge to Microsoft.
So how does the open-source approach translate into mainstream businesses practices?
"In the open-source model, leaders are more like peers," Wolf explained last week. "A leader will start a project, write the initial code base, then create a dialogue with a community, and integrate their contributions. That's different from top-down project management."
"The way open-source projects are designed is also different, more modular," Lakhani added. "People need pieces that they can grab, work on, and be proud of."
Such open-source-like ideas can already be found in unexpected places. For example, Wolf and Lakhani say, Harley-Davidson, the venerable motorcycle manufacturer, encourages customers to extensively modify their models by working with other companies that produce various accessories for the bikes. In effect, the company willingly cedes some control to the owners and outside firms.
To Wolf and Lakhani, that approach reflects an open-source attitude, and goes a long way toward explaining why Harley-Davidson has consistently enjoyed such high customer loyalty.
Similarly, Lego, the toy manufacturer, has allowed computer programmers who do not work for the company to have access to the code that controls its Mindstorm toy robot. The result: The outsider programmers have increased the range of activities the robot can perform in ways the company never imagined.
And John Fluevog Shoes, based in Vancouver, allows customers to submit ideas to the company for development, and vote on the designs they want to see manufactured. That marketing concept amounts to "open-source footwear," said Jeff Bates, the director of the Open Source Development Network Online, an Internet-based gathering for open-source programmers. His group also worked on the survey conducted by Wolf and Lakhani.
"The survey confirmed what I knew in my gut," Bates said. "Open-source developers are inspired by a cluster of reasons: The projects are interesting, they get to work with smart people, they sharpen their skills, and they help to build products that they need."
For companies (and consulting groups) trying to find new ways to manage projects, interact with customers, and improve their products, tapping into these kinds of motivations can lead to surprising innovations, as they have at Harley-Davidson, Lego, John Fluevog Shoes, and elsewhere.
"Open-source is kind of scary," Bates said. "You're opening things up and inviting people to contribute. But if it works, you discover that the world has a lot of good ideas, and you're able to build something that they want to happen."
Posted: Tuesday, February 19, 2002
Sunday Globe - Interpublic, one of the largest advertising agencies in the world, wasted little time after business commenced last Monday in announcing a dramatic shakeup of its board of directors.
In a brief statement, the company said that four Interpublic executives would resign from the board to reduce its size and also increase the percentage of members with no company connections.
"The interests of our shareholders will be better served by a board that is smaller, and has a higher proportion of outside, independent directors," chief executive John Dooner added in the release, which noted that he and chief financial officer Sean Orr will now be the only two Interpublic executives on the nine-member board.
While Dooner said the board changes had been planned for more than a year, it's a safe bet the expanding Enron scandal was a factor behind the timing of the announcement. Suddenly, in the post-Enron era, investors are turning a critical eye toward corporate boards, questioning whether they have been vigilant in overseeing management and protecting shareholders' interests.
"The free ride is over," said Patrick McGurn, a vice president at Institutional Shareholder Services, a group based in Rockville, Md., that analyzes corporate governance issues for large institutional investors.
"In the good old days, even if a company melted down, the directors walked off without any damage to their reputations," McGurn added. "People used to say, `You can't hold the directors responsible.' Well investors aren't saying that about Enron's board, and now they aren't likely to say it about other company boards either."
Where was the board? That's a question that has been asked with increasing frequency, whether the troubled company is Polaroid Corp., Global Crossing Ltd., or Tyco International Ltd.
In Enron's case, the question is particularly pointed: Critics note that the board was stacked with insiders with financial ties to the company and that the board's audit committee rubber-stamped a series of questionable accounting partnerships. The board even voted to waive Enron's own ethics policy, allowing the company's CFO to serve as general partner in partnerships that had financial transactions with Enron.
The consequences of these lapses, for Enron directors, have been swift and severe. Last week, Enron said that seven board members would resign, including four directors from the highly criticized audit committee.
A special board committee led by William Powers, the dean of the University of Texas law school, chastized the board for examining Enron's off-balance sheet transactions in only a "cursory way." And the AFL-CIO has formally asked the Securities and Exchange Commission to bar all Enron directors from serving on any other boards, claiming that they would pose "an imminent danger" to employees' retirement savings.
The most significant consequences of the Enron debacle will likely be felt far beyond Enron, however, in corporate boardrooms nationwide, say corporate governance specialists.
"The first board meetings after Enron are going to be very interesting," said Robert Raber, president of the National Association of Corporate Directors. "Board members are going to be asking a lot of questions. ... The board will also be examining themselves: What kind of conflicts do we have."
Although membership on a corporate board is often regarded as an honorary capstone to a successful business career, directors have a prominent place in the corporate hierarchy. Corporations are owned by shareholders; boards are accountable to shareholders; managers, including the CEO, answer to the board. In the modern corporate model, board members are expected to exercise careful management oversight.
Interpublic, in its announcement last week, stressed that it was moving to a largely independent board of directors "in recognition of corporate governance best practices." The company announced the addition of one prominent new outside member, Michael Roth, head of The MONY Group, praising him for having "the highest professional and ethical standards."
According to Raber, whose group tracks trends in corporate boards, compensation for corporate directors often depends on the size of the company. The most recent NACD survey showed that small public companies pay board members an average of $44,000 a year, consisting of 40 percent stock and 60 percent cash; the largest 200 corporations pay an average of $137,000 a year, of which 60 percent is in stock and 40 percent in cash.
A typical board member for a large public company should expect to spend " 200 hours a year" on the job, including meetings, research, and interaction with company officers, Raber said, although he acknowledged that many board members probably devote much less time to the job.
That may soon change. Shortly after the Enron collapse, Raber issued an alert to association members listing "some basic issues for director focus." Raber warned board members to double their efforts to understand financial reporting practices; to question needless complexity; to strive to protect employee retirement plans; to be more careful about conflicts of interest and rules concerning insider trading; and to work harder to create "a climate of integrity and responsibility."
This added responsibility, Raber believes, will increase demands on board members.
"If a prospective board member seems reluctant, or unable, to make a significant commitment, I now advise the search committee to put on their track shoes and run away from him as fast as they can," he said. "The job is much more complex now. A minimal approach won't work."
The due diligence is not only on the company's side, Raber said.
"Many prospective board members are asking a lot of questions now. They want to know what they can realistically contribute, and if there is a climate of disclosure. They don't want to be the last to know about problems."
Board members are also worried about personal liability. Although directors are typically covered by insurance policies that protect them from shareholder lawsuits, the coverage evaporates if fraud or criminal conduct is involved.
Also asking questions with renewed energy are groups that represent shareholders and institutional investors in advocating for a variety of corporate governance reforms.
"For us, the Enron situation has been a good thing, in that we no longer seem like fringe group, or gadflies," said Ann Yerger, director of research at the Council of Institutional Investors, based in Washington, which represents the interests of more than 250 pension funds and $2 trillion in assets.
The council has persistently advocated for more outside board members since its formation in the mid-1980s. Now that the issue is in front of congressional committees, Yerger is more confident that change will happen, especially since the reform movement has the backing of such investor behemoths as the California Public Employees' Retirement System.
"It's common sense," she said. "As an investor, you want to know board members are comfortable asking the hard questions. You don't want them beholden to the company in any way."
Yerger and others point to recent examples that show that company troubles can often be traced to the boardroom. Tyco found itself trying to explain why it paid an outside director $20 million for his help in brokering an acquisition; Global Crossing's board has been lambasted for approving an excessive contract for chief executive Robert Annunziata; and Polaroid's board has been criticized for not protecting the employee pension plan as the company slid into bankruptcy.
Charles Elson, director of the Center for Corporate Governance at the University of Delaware, put the matter bluntly. "There will be increased demand for independence," he said, "no financial connection to the company at all."
At the same time, Elson says, board members may soon be required to make substantial, long-term investments in company stock, as a way of aligning board and shareholder interests.
Some CEOs and board members are also agitating for change. Harry Gray, former CEO of Hartford-based United Technologies Corp., who served on a number of corporate boards, says that some boards have gotten "a bit lax, kind of clubby" in recent years. But he believes the solution is more vigilance by board members.
"At United Technologies, I expected my board members to understand the product lines and the operations," Gray said. "I wanted them to know the managers."
If a director didn't take the job seriously, Gray says, he did not hesitate to ask him to resign.
"I did that quite a few times," he said, using a brief, standard letter suggesting that the board member did not have the time or inclination to fulfill his duties.
Gray says he took his own board positions seriously. He served on the boards of Exxon Mobil Corp., Union Carbide Corp., Citigroup, and Aetna Inc.
"I never served on more than three boards at one time," Gray said. "And I had a personal rule that I wouldn't accept membership on a board unless I felt I could interrogate the managers."
Gray often used his position on the board to play an active role in the company. As a member of the Union Carbide board in the mid-'80s, for example, Gray helped rebuff a hostile takeover by GAF Corp. by personally directing the divestiture of a number of Union Carbide brands.
"I had experience buying and selling companies," Gray said, "The CEO needed that experience and asked me to make the deals. I was happy to oblige."
For less motivated board members and corporations, corporate governance experts say, the path to improved board performance may require new regulations from the SEC or the stock exchanges, which currently mandate basic board requirements for the companies they list. Individual states, which regulate the corporations within their borders, also have the power to require greater board independence and oversight.
By far, however, the most significant influence in changing board behavior is likely to be investors themselves.
"The financial markets will ultimately determine how corporate boards evolve," said McGurn, of Institutional Shareholder Services. He noted that board-related transgressions at Tyco and Nortel Networks Corp., where an executive and board member recently resigned after admitting to insider trading, both caused significant sell-offs by investors, with resulting declines in the stock price.
"If a company's stock price starts heading down and there's a perception that the board isn't doing its part," McGurn said, "the changes will come. The boards will change, whether they want to or not."
Posted: Friday, February 15, 2002
Friday productivity killers - Bored at work? Here are a few things that might pique your interest and provide some much needed comic-relief. Check back every Friday for the best in time-wasting Web diversions.
See if you can beat the Ninja Delivery Game.
Your company needs to downsize, what do you do? Play Pinkslip Panic, that's what.
I don't know what else this guy does, but he does know
How to Dance.
Why should there be only a certain number of musical genres, when you could have millions!
Do you have a curious mind? So do search engine spy sites....see what people are looking for.
Posted: Monday, February 4, 2002
Sunday Globe - Pick a number.
Four? According to Paul Lawrence and Nitin Nohria, both professors at the Harvard Business School, "four primary innate drives are hard-wired into the brains of all humans." "Driven," their new book, lays them out so business leaders can "tape the positive powers of these inborn drives."
Forty-eight? Author Robert Greene claims that by observing the rules in his bestseller, "The 48 Laws of Power," you "will gain more power, and by transgressing them you will inevitably suffer a decrease."
One? Hey, I can answer that. The new number one rule for aspiring business book authors is: Don't write, enumerate. Unnoticed in BusinessWeek's recent list of 2001's business bestsellers was that no less than six of the titles are list-like: "The 21 Irrefutable Laws of Leadership," "The 9 Steps to Financial Freedom," etc.
Paul B. Brown, who has authored, coauthored, and ghost-written nearly 20 business books from an office overlooking a cranberry bog in Duxbury, isn't surprised.
"Blame Stephen Covey and `The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People,"' he said, referring to the 1990 book that has sold more than 10 million copies. "That got the number thing going. Not only do readers like the format, it gives business writers a mechanism to organize their books."
Brown obviously likes the "list of lessons" approach. Four of his business titles are built around numbers.
"When I worked at Forbes," he said, "the editor, Jim Michaels, used to say that if you give a reader just one idea per issue, he'll keep subscribing. I've sort of extended that to books. My approach is that if you give the reader three good ideas that he can put to work immediately, he will think he's gotten his money's worth."
With CEO biographies/autobiographies in eclipse, look for numbered lessons to continue multiplying on business booklists.
The Patriots weren't the only team that kicked butt last week. In the battle of the crisis consultants, the Arthur Andersen accounting team of three communications firms (Chlopak, Leonard, Schechter & Associates; Griffin Johnson Dover & Stewart; and Ketchum) pummeled the Enron crew in the early rounds.
Ashley McCown, a senior vice president at Boston-based Bishoff Solomon Communications who heads up the firm's crisis communications practice, has been keeping score.
"Andersen did everything right," she said. "They quickly fired the guy who shredded the documents, they developed message points underscoring how they were going to address the problem, and they immediately got their CEO out there: testifying to Congress, talking to the press, writing opinion pieces."
"Enron and [ex-CEO] Ken Lay haven't been proactive," McCown said.
Posted: February 8, 2002
Here's a new genre: News Gaming. Check out the Enron Blame Game. I hope they keep updating it. It could develop into an online corporate Survivor.
There's been so much anticipation of GPS-enabled location-based services, it's difficult to believe that the idea will ever get real. But the CoolTown project is giving me hope. New Scientist describes a few developments, like leaving a message in the air.
And it's worth remembering that, despite all the booming and busting that has gone on in the Internet space, Web usage continues to grow, steadily. The U.S. government has a new, relevant study on Internet Usage.
(thanks: E-Media Tidbits).
Posted: Monday, February 4, 2002
Sunday Globe - Professor Jay Thibodeau was at the blackboard one afternoon last week, energetically charting basic accounting principles for students in his "Fundamentals of Auditing" course at Bentley College in Waltham.
Early in the class, Thibodeau mapped two groups on the board: "upper management" and "investors, creditors." He left a large expanse of gray between them.
"This is where accountancy comes into play," he said, pointing to the empty space between the two groups. "Can the investors and creditors trust the numbers they are getting from upper management?"
Hey professor, a lot of people are asking that same question these days. The sudden collapse of the nation's seventh-largest company will naturally start people wondering about standards in corporate finance, conflicts of interest, and the role of "accountancy."
But at Bentley, which has trained generations of accountants (it was founded in 1917 as the Bentley College of Accounting and Finance), the questions are much bigger, much broader. Like whether the current business reporting model is just plain broken.
Thibodeau thinks that it is.
"The accounting model we're working with now was developed for the industrial age," he told the class that afternoon. "It worked for companies like U.S. Steel. It doesn't necessarily work for Enron."
Specifically, Thibodeau says the current accounting model lacks standardized measures for many of the nonfinancial metrics that are commonly used in many information-age companies. And although Enron's business was energy, many of its accounting practices were borrowed from "new economy" companies.
During the class, Thibodeau brought up the example of AOL.
"The number of customers, the number of new customers, the number of page views -- those metrics are very important in the Internet sector," he said.
"Why not have a standardized measurement display of these nonfinancial performance measures?" he asked as he paced in front of the class. "These things can be measured, and audited."
Thibodeau, in fact, is currently working on a research project with three colleagues that is studying the information used by sell-side financial analysts in making their buy-sell stock recommendations. Thibodeau says that they've already discovered that analysts appear to use "massive" amounts of information that is not independently audited.
In some respects, Thibodeau's work is part of a larger movement that is attempting to expand the purview of accounting. Bentley's accountancy department, for example, now offers popular combo degrees in "accounting and finance" and "accounting and computer science" -- to train students to better capture the new realities of business.
And the entire accounting profession is still debating a broad study sponsored by the Financial Accounting Standards Board that urges an expansion of the standard financial model to include data and performance measurements that are not captured by traditional annual reports.
Up to now, many businesses have fiercely, and successfully, resisted expanded reports. Thibodeau goaded the class to consider some reasons why: additional costs; fear of compromising competitive secrets; more data for litigious investors.
But it didn't take much coaxing to determine why lobbyists for those objections may be losing their power.
A student in the third row raised her hand and said just one word: "Enron."
"As accountants, we measure. That's what we do," Thibodeau told his class that afternoon.
Thanks to the Enron/Andersen debacle, Thibodeau and his students may soon be getting more data to measure.
Posted: Monday, January 15, 2002
OnSite: Natick - There was a confusing moment, as I was sitting in Dave and Ina
Steiner's living room, when the two of them attempted to
calculate the number of hours they spend per week on AuctionBytes, the
newsy Web site they run that covers the online auction business in general,
and eBay in particular.
"I'd say sixty hours," Dave said.
"That's about it," Ina agreed.
"Total, right?" they were asked.
"Oh no, each," Dave replied.
"Definitely each, at least," Ina added. "There's just so much going
on."
Ina would know. The Web auction business, which took off with the
launch of eBay in 1995, has been expanding at a tremendous pace. It's no
surprise that an auction beat reporter's hours are adding up.
Some recent developments at eBay highlight how the sector is
expanding. eBay is now promoting special non-auction sections for large
retail powerhouses like Disney, Ritz Camera, and Sears. The online auctioneer is also now selling new industrial-grade high-tech equipment to
corporate IT managers -- stuff like servers and routers. During the last
few months, eBay announced two separate marketing agreements: a loyalty
partnership with Burger King -- kind of a frequent flier deal with burgers
and fries -- and a preferred marketing arrangement IBM. Many items for sale
on eBay are not auctions at all: instead visitors are urged to "Buy now!"
at a fixed price.
What happened to the folksy online flea market, where collectors bid
on Bozo the Clown bobble head dolls and Battlestar Galactica wallets?
That's why I was in Natick: to get an update from two pre-eminent
auction watchers.
"The new buzzword at eBay is 'practicals'," Ina Steiner said at the
start of her analysis. "A 'practical' is something that is not a
collectible: a tool, a digital camera, a coat."
"Practicals sell to consumers, not collectors, and that's where eBay
wants to go," she added.
"They've got the collectors," Dave Steiner adds. "Now they want to get
consumers."
The Steiners, who've been married 13 years, often engage in
Click-and-Clack-style bantering on auction topics. Dave often takes the
side of the small collectors; Ina is more interested in how eBay's is
starting to deal with big corporate partners. They do agree on a few key
points however, like the fact that it's now tougher for the mom-and-pop
collectors who traditionally have bought and sold on eBay.
"The smaller eBay merchants are now competing against much bigger
companies, with bigger marketing budgets and larger inventories," said
Dave.
Signicantly eBay's CEO, Meg Whitman, now refers to the company as "the
world's largest online marketplace." Auctions are now just a part of a much
larger strategy.
The strategy is not without its risks. Selling new items -- digital
cameras, computers, etc. -- puts eBay in direct competition with
established online retail operations, like Amazon, and real-world big box
stores like Circuit City.
Neglecting smaller collectors could take a toll too. Yahoo is now
opportunistically trying to win over disgruntled eBay merchants. And dozens
of smaller niche auction sites are siphoning away some of the loyalists.
Why sell your "Bewitched" lunch box on eBay, when you can put it on an
auction site dedicated exclusively to lunch boxes?
Of course there's always the possibility that eBay can have it both
ways: appealing to both collectors and consumers. The Steiners disagree
about this scenerio. Ina thinks it's possible. Dave isn't so sure.
"It's still early in the game," he said.
So it will take many 120-hour weeks before any of us find out?
On this last point there was no disagreement. Both quickly nodded
their heads yes.